LATEST REPORT: Eddie Howe bemoans VAR decisions that cost Newcastle two points against Everton
Newcastle United fans definitely felt it was a case of two points dropped last night as an 88th-minute penalty saw Everton rescue a point at St James’ Park.
The Magpies should have comfortably secured victory well before substitute Paul Dummett’s decisive foul on Ashley Young in the box, a moment that had seemingly no imminent danger.
In our post-match analysis last night, I found it challenging to refrain from expressing frustration towards Paul Dummett in colorful language. However, upon reflection, it’s difficult to place excessive blame on him, considering his limited game time over the past two years. It’s understandable that he may have felt nervous, panicked, and eager to make an impact, which unfortunately led to the penalty incident.
To be honest, I was surprised that there was any doubt regarding the penalty decision, as it appeared to be a clear-cut foul. Nevertheless, it’s noteworthy that Eddie Howe wasn’t entirely convinced, highlighting differing perspectives on the incident.
Howe’s comments on the penalty didn’t make much sensec
After the game, Howe spoke to TNT Sport about the disallowed goal and the penalty call, citing two instances in which VAR intervened in close rulings. This raised the question of whether he felt unfairly treated in the penalty call.
“I believe that both players are fighting, but sadly for us, Paul’s arm was raised quite a bit around Ashley Young. I believe this was the deciding factor for VAR. Still, it’s one of those situations when anything might have happened.”
Until Dummett put Young in a headlock and pulled the frail elderly guy to the ground, it was in fact two players grappling.
Newcastle should have had the game wrapped up before the penalty incident
I completely agree. While it’s tempting to see things in a simplistic light or stick to rigid viewpoints, there are moments when it’s necessary to acknowledge the reality and take responsibility. In this case, there are no excuses – it was unequivocally a penalty.
In the broader context, the penalty incident shouldn’t have been the deciding factor, as Newcastle had numerous opportunities to secure victory earlier in the match. However, commendable goalkeeping by Jordan Pickford and some questionable decision-making in the final third prevented us from extending our lead and putting the game beyond doubt.
Ultimately, the impact of substitutions was pivotal. Sean Dyche’s alterations improved his team’s performance, while Eddie Howe’s forced substitution had a detrimental effect on our side, ultimately costing us the win. It’s a tough lesson, but one we must learn from moving forward.