REPORT: Houston Astros to replace Alex Bregman’s bat with elite slugger from AL rival in free agency

If the Houston Astros were to lose Alex Bregman in free agency, ESPN MLB insider David Schoenfield suggests they might pursue Juan Soto to replace his bat in the lineup. Soto is widely regarded as one of the premier offensive talents in MLB, and he could provide the kind of elite on-base ability and power the Astros would need to maintain their championship aspirations.

Soto, set to become a free agent after the 2024 season, is expected to command one of the largest contracts in baseball history. While the Astros have historically been cautious with mega-deals, pursuing Soto could be a statement move to ensure their lineup remains potent, particularly with questions about Bregman’s future and Kyle Tucker’s contract status looming.

Landing a player like Soto would signal Houston’s commitment to staying competitive in the American League and mitigating the loss of a franchise cornerstone like Bregman. However, such a move would also come with financial challenges and competition from other teams looking to secure Soto’s services.

Houston Astros predicted to replace Alex Bregman with Anthony Santander this offseason

If the Houston Astros lose Alex Bregman in free agency, Anthony Santander could emerge as a key target for the team to fill the offensive void, according to ESPN MLB insider David Schoenfield. Santander, a switch-hitting outfielder for the Baltimore Orioles, has quietly been a consistent run producer and power hitter, making him an appealing option for the Astros.

Schoenfield notes that the Astros’ lineup would need reinforcements, especially considering the lack of depth in the outfield beyond Kyle Tucker and Yordan Alvarez, the latter being better suited as a full-time designated hitter. Santander, who has showcased a combination of power and versatility, could slot effectively into left field and provide much-needed balance in the middle of Houston’s lineup.

While Santander may not be a top-tier free agent like Juan Soto, his affordability and proven offensive track record make him an attractive option for a team looking to remain competitive without committing to another massive contract. Adding Santander would allow Houston to replace a portion of Bregman’s offensive production while maintaining financial flexibility for future decisions regarding Tucker and other stars.

Anthony Santander’s emergence as one of the American League’s top power hitters makes him an appealing target for the Houston Astros, especially if they lose Alex Bregman in free agency. Santander had a breakout 2024 season, belting 44 home runs for the Baltimore Orioles, solidifying his reputation as a reliable middle-of-the-order bat.

At 30 years old, Santander is in his prime, offering an attractive mix of power and consistency. His anticipated price tag of $100–$120 million aligns with the Astros’ financial comfort zone, particularly if they are unwilling to meet Bregman’s rumored $200 million asking price. This makes Santander a more affordable and viable option for bolstering their lineup.

Adding Santander would help Houston address their offensive needs, especially in left field, while allowing Yordan Alvarez to transition fully to the designated hitter role. His presence in the middle of the lineup would complement Kyle Tucker and keep the Astros competitive in the AL West, ensuring they have the power and depth needed to contend for another deep postseason run.