BREAKING: Cardinals Face Tough Decisions on Trading Veterans Like Helsley and Fedde Amid Playoff Uncertainty
The St. Louis Cardinals could face another year without a playoff appearance, potentially prompting them to trade several impending free agents at the deadline. If the team struggles to stay competitive, they may prioritize selling valuable assets over chasing a postseason spot. This approach could lead to significant roster changes, particularly among pitchers with expiring contracts, as the Cardinals shift their focus to rebuilding.
One notable trade candidate is Ryan Helsley, the 2021 National League Reliever of the Year, who is set to become a free agent after the 2025 season. Helsley’s stellar bullpen performance would likely draw interest from playoff-bound teams if the Cardinals fall out of contention by the deadline. Trading Helsley would align with the team’s broader plan to part with veterans and prioritize future development.
Another pitcher who could be on the move is Erick Fedde, whom the Cardinals acquired from the Chicago White Sox in 2024. Fedde struggled early in his career with the Washington Nationals but found success after a stint in the Korean Baseball Organization. In 2024, he posted a solid 3.11 ERA, making him a key part of the St. Louis rotation, and potentially a valuable trade asset.
With a 3.30 ERA, a 9-9 record, and a strong strikeout-to-walk ratio in 2024, Fedde’s performance could make him a prime trade candidate if the Cardinals are not in playoff contention. If he continues to pitch well in 2025, Fedde could yield a strong return, aiding St. Louis in bolstering their farm system and supporting their rebuilding plans.
The Cardinals’ approach for 2025 will depend on their early-season results. If they remain competitive in the NL Central, they may hold onto veterans like Fedde and Helsley for a potential postseason push. However, if they fall out of the race, the team is likely to become sellers, trading players like Fedde to maximize value and secure assets for the future.