REPORT: Padres add All-Star catcher to reinforce battery
It sounds like the Padres could really benefit from upgrading their catcher position. With free agency approaching, a veteran All-Star catcher might be exactly what they need to add stability behind the plate, especially if their current roster lacks consistent offensive or defensive production at the position.
Do you have a particular free-agent catcher in mind, like Yasmani Grandal or someone similar, who fits that “been-around-the-way” description? Or are you curious about other potential trade targets or prospects that could fill the gap?
Padres could reinforce battery with James McCann signing
The Padres are clearly exploring all avenues to address their catching situation, but James McCann seems like an interesting option given his past All-Star experience. While his offensive production in 2024 with the Orioles (.234/.279/.388) might not jump off the page, his veteran presence and defensive skills could provide the stability San Diego needs behind the plate.
That said, the financial constraints highlighted by Robert Murray make things tricky. If McCann is out of their budget, pivoting to trade options makes sense. The idea of potentially trading high-profile players like Dylan Cease, Jake Cronenworth, or even the NL batting champ Luis Arraez suggests the Padres are willing to get creative—but moving players of that caliber could come with significant ripple effects on the roster.
What do you think of McCann as an option, or do you think the Padres should prioritize someone else? Also, how do you feel about potentially parting ways with players like Arraez or Cease to make this happen?
McCann would give offensive boost to Padres
That’s a solid point—McCann would provide much-needed depth and experience for the Padres’ catching unit, especially with Kyle Higashioka now with the Rangers. Comparing the two, McCann’s .234 batting average in 2024 might not seem stellar, but it’s a noticeable improvement over Higashioka’s .216. Plus, matching Campusano in home runs while playing 26 fewer games highlights McCann’s ability to contribute offensively in limited action.
For a team like the Padres, balancing veteran depth with the continued development of Campusano seems like the right move. McCann’s presence could also provide mentorship for Campusano, ensuring stability while the younger catcher continues to refine his game. Do you think the Padres should prioritize McCann over other free agents, or could a trade for a more impactful player behind the plate make more sense?