Report: The Phillies and Pirates have had trade conversations about closer David Bednar and setup man Dennis Santana. The feeling is Philly could want BOTH in a deal. Stay tuned.”
— Andrew Fillipponi (@ThePoniExpress) June 30, 2025
Key Points from the Report:
-
While this isn’t from a national writer, a Pittsburgh sports-radio host indicates the conversation came from someone with RPGs to the front office—it can’t be dismissed.
-
David Bednar
-
Was in a slump last season and even demoted to Triple-A.
-
Since returning to the majors, he’s logged 27⅔ innings with 40 strikeouts, just six walks, and a sterling 1.95 ERA.
-
Notably, he’s allowed only one homer since April 19.
Dennis Santana
-
Even more impressive so far this season: 36 innings, 28 strikeouts, six walks, boasting a 1.50 ERA and 1.8 bWAR.
-
His peripherals back up his strong ERA, indicating solid and sustainable performance.
-
Collectively, acquiring both would provide a significant bullpen upgrade for the Phillies.
-
Crucially, both pitchers are under team control beyond 2025, increasing their appeal and value in trade negotiations.
-
-
Why It Matters
The Phillies have a pressing need for late-inning bullpen help as they eye a postseason push. If they secure both Bednar and Santana, it could be a decisive move to fortify their pen without sacrificing future flexibility.
Bottom line:
Trade conversations between the Phillies and Pirates spotlight bids for both David Bednar and Dennis Santana as a potential package deal. While early in the rumor cycle, both relievers offer impressive, controllable value that aligns well with Philly’s bullpen needs.
