The 2025 season will go down as one of the darkest chapters in recent New York Mets history—a season that began with high expectations and playoff dreams, only to unravel into one of the most stunning collapses Major League Baseball has seen in decades. A team once considered a near-lock for the postseason, filled with star power and momentum, saw its hopes fade into heartbreak as the months dragged on. What was supposed to be a triumphant encore to last year’s playoff run turned instead into a cautionary tale about inconsistency, missed opportunities, and perhaps a deeper identity crisis within the franchise.
From the very beginning of the season, the Mets carried the burden of expectation. Their front office had built a roster designed to contend—mixing established veterans with emerging stars, all under the bright lights of a city that demands success. Fans envisioned October baseball, a chance to reclaim relevance in a fiercely competitive National League. For a while, those dreams seemed realistic. The Mets opened strong, hovering among the league’s top teams through the first two months. The offense clicked, the pitching held firm, and Citi Field buzzed with the kind of optimism that had eluded Queens for far too long.
But baseball has a cruel way of humbling even the most confident teams. By midseason, warning signs began to emerge. The Mets’ bullpen showed cracks. Their lineup, once potent, began to stall at key moments. Injuries to key contributors compounded their troubles, and what had been a minor slump turned into something much more alarming. Then came the losing streaks—brutal, demoralizing stretches that exposed the team’s fragility.
“The Mets lost 7 straight in June. They lost 7 straight again in August. They lost 8 straight in September,” noted Opta Stats, highlighting a historical rarity. “The only team in MLB history to have three separate 7+ game losing streaks and yet still make the playoffs was the 2006 Cardinals, who went on to win the World Series that year.”
For Mets fans, that comparison only made the collapse sting more. The 2006 Cardinals had turned their adversity into triumph, rallying at the perfect moment. The 2025 Mets, however, couldn’t find the same magic. Every attempt to regain footing was followed by another stumble. Each series loss dug the hole deeper, until by late September, the once-promising season had slipped away completely.
The players, too, seemed weighed down by the mounting frustration. Locker room interviews turned somber. The optimism that once radiated from the clubhouse was replaced by a tone of resignation. Team leaders tried to remain composed, but even they couldn’t disguise the disappointment.
And no player embodied the emotional tug-of-war of the Mets’ season more than Pete Alonso. The face of the franchise and one of the league’s most feared sluggers, Alonso’s future became one of the biggest storylines in New York as the season wound down. While his production at the plate remained strong, his comments off the field sparked speculation about whether he was already envisioning life beyond Citi Field.
“Playing for this organization, this city—they’ve continued to believe in me,” Alonso said in a reflective postgame interview. “I love playing here. There’s some great guys in this clubhouse, some great people on the staff. Every single day, it’s been a pleasure coming to work and putting on the orange and blue. I’ve really appreciated it and have been nothing but full of gratitude every single day. Nothing is guaranteed, but we’ll see what happens—I’ve loved being a Met. Hopefully, they’ve appreciated me the same.”
It was a heartfelt statement, but one that carried an unmistakable undertone of uncertainty. For all his gratitude, Alonso didn’t commit to a long-term future in New York. His words left fans and analysts alike wondering: was this a goodbye in slow motion?
Alonso has always been more than just a power hitter for the Mets. Since bursting onto the scene with a record-setting rookie season, he’s served as a symbol of the team’s hope and resilience—a homegrown star who embraced the city’s pressure and passion. Yet the Mets’ inability to sustain success around him may finally be wearing thin. For a competitor like Alonso, enduring yet another disappointing finish could make a change of scenery appealing.
If Alonso does indeed test the market, one team has already been floated as a potential landing spot: the Boston Red Sox. According to Bleacher Report’s Kerry Miller, Boston could be among the most aggressive suitors should Alonso leave Queens. “So, while there’s a good chance they either re-sign Bregman or bring in either Alonso or Bo Bichette, it’s unlikely they’ll sign multiple members of that trio,” Miller wrote. “We shall see which one they prefer.”
The Red Sox, like the Mets, are navigating their own transitional phase. After several uneven seasons following their 2018 championship, Boston has been searching for an identity and a cornerstone around whom to rebuild. Alonso could be exactly that—an elite slugger whose combination of charisma, work ethic, and power would fit seamlessly into Fenway Park’s culture. His ability to mash to all fields would play beautifully in front of the Green Monster, and his intensity would resonate with the passionate Boston fanbase.
For Alonso, Boston could represent more than just a new team—it could be a fresh start. The Mets’ struggles have often overshadowed his individual excellence, and the constant swirl of contract rumors has added unnecessary noise. In a new environment, especially one as storied as Boston, Alonso could reassert himself as one of the game’s premier offensive talents while enjoying the stability that has eluded him in New York.
Of course, the idea of Alonso in a Red Sox uniform would be bittersweet for Mets fans. Losing a player who has been the heart of the franchise for years would mark the end of an era. But for an organization in search of direction, tough decisions may be necessary. The Mets have to ask themselves whether investing heavily in a long-term deal for Alonso aligns with their broader vision—or whether reallocating those resources toward pitching, depth, and development might yield a more sustainable future.
The offseason ahead promises to be pivotal. The front office will need to confront hard truths about what went wrong in 2025 and what needs to change to avoid a repeat. Was the collapse a product of poor roster construction, bad luck, or deeper systemic issues? How much of the responsibility falls on the coaching staff, and how much on the players themselves? These are questions that will shape the next chapter of Mets baseball.
Meanwhile, the specter of what could have been will loom large. This season will forever serve as a reminder that talent alone doesn’t guarantee success—that chemistry, depth, and resilience matter just as much as star power. The Mets’ inability to respond to adversity revealed a fragility that must be addressed if they hope to compete with the likes of Atlanta, Los Angeles, or Philadelphia in the years to come.
For Alonso, the coming months could define his legacy. Does he double down on loyalty, hoping to help bring a championship to the team that drafted him? Or does he chase a new opportunity, one that might give him a clearer path to October glory? Either way, his next move will carry major implications not only for his career but for the direction of both franchises involved.
As winter approaches, the disappointment of this season will continue to hang over Flushing. The sting of missed opportunities and squandered leads won’t fade quickly. But baseball, ever cyclical, always offers the promise of renewal. Perhaps the pain of collapse will fuel the Mets’ determination to rebuild stronger, wiser, and more united.
Still, for now, the memory of 2025 remains raw. A season that began with dreams of a deep playoff run instead ended in disillusionment, the Mets watching from home as other teams chase the glory they once seemed destined for. The questions surrounding Pete Alonso’s future only add another layer of uncertainty to an offseason already clouded with doubt.
If this truly marks the end of Alonso’s time in New York, it will close a significant chapter in Mets history—a story of brilliance, frustration, and what-ifs. Whether he stays or goes, his impact on the organization and its fans is undeniable. He has been a beacon of effort and consistency amid chaos, a player who always left everything on the field.
For the Mets, redemption won’t come easily. But baseball’s beauty lies in its endurance—the next season always offers another chance. For now, though, the team and its fans must sit with the bitter reality of one of the most shocking collapses in MLB history and the uncertainty of what lies ahead.
READ MORE MLB NEWS:
