The Philadelphia Phillies are currently in a holding pattern as they wait to learn which opponent they’ll face when their postseason journey officially begins. Thanks to a dominant regular season, they secured a coveted first-round bye, giving them time to rest, reset, and fully lock in on their ultimate mission — bringing another World Series championship back to Philadelphia.
While the focus in the clubhouse is entirely on October baseball, that doesn’t mean the front office isn’t already thinking one step ahead. In fact, it’s safe to assume that the Phillies’ decision-makers are already mapping out potential moves for the offseason, exploring ways to not only maintain but also strengthen a roster that has already proven capable of contending for a title.
One particularly intriguing scenario has been floated recently, and it involves one of the biggest names in baseball. Kerry Miller of Bleacher Report suggested that the Phillies could emerge as one of the top suitors for New York Mets star slugger Pete Alonso once the offseason arrives.
Miller raised the possibility of Philadelphia losing Kyle Schwarber in free agency, which would create a major void in the lineup. He posed the question: “What if they fail to re-sign Kyle Schwarber, though, resulting in a void at DH to be filled by Harper and/or Castellanos? Doesn’t Alonso’s 158 home runs since the beginning of 2022 become the logical top target to backfill the 187 home runs Schwarber has hit during that time?”
There’s no denying Alonso’s pedigree as a power bat. In the 2025 season with the Mets, the 30-year-old first baseman suited up for all 162 games and delivered another standout campaign. He crushed 38 home runs, drove in 126 runs, and posted an impressive slash line of .272/.347/.525 with a strong .871 OPS. Those numbers reaffirm why he’s viewed as one of the premier sluggers in the game today.
At 30 years old, Alonso still has plenty left in the tank, and if the Phillies were to lose Schwarber, adding him would be a massive move to keep their offense among the league’s most dangerous. Ideally, Philadelphia would prefer to retain Schwarber, whose left-handed power and postseason heroics have made him a fan favorite. But if circumstances force a change, pivoting to Alonso would hardly be a downgrade — in fact, it might even elevate the lineup in different ways.
Of course, this is all speculation at the moment. The Phillies aren’t in offseason mode just yet; they still have postseason baseball to play, and their primary mission is winning in October. But with Alonso’s future in New York uncertain and the Phillies’ front office always searching for an edge, this is a storyline worth keeping tabs on as the offseason approaches.
