Josh Allen gets completely disrespected in recent QB power rankings

Anyone who followed the league last year knows Josh Allen was the best quarterback in football—earning his first MVP award and carrying the Buffalo Bills on his back. Without him, Buffalo likely wouldn’t have won more than five games. Instead, Allen led them to a 13–4 record, transforming a reshuffled offense into one of the league’s most potent units despite offseason losses at key skill positions.

Oh, and let’s not overlook the history-making numbers. Allen became the first player in NFL history to post 40+ total touchdowns in five straight seasons. He shattered franchise records and added even more firepower to his already elite résumé. Simply put: Allen deserves to be at the very top of any quarterback rankings—yes, even above Patrick Mahomes.

Just ask Bills Mafia. Allen isn’t just the face of the franchise—he is the franchise. He’s the engine behind Buffalo’s championship window, the leader of the locker room, and he’s never missed a game in six seasons. He averages 30 passing touchdowns per year with a completion rate north of 63%. Not bad for a guy whose accuracy was once his biggest knock coming out of Wyoming.

And yet, somehow, some analysts still aren’t giving him his flowers. CBS Sports’ Cody Benjamin recently released his post-draft QB power rankings—and had Allen fifth. Behind Lamar Jackson, Joe Burrow, Jalen Hurts, and… Jayden Daniels?

Allen is coming off his most efficient season to date, thriving with a revamped receiving corps and once again proving he can elevate everyone around him. Like Lamar Jackson, he’s still chasing a win over the Chiefs in the postseason. But let’s be clear: there’s no argument—Allen is already at the top of the mountain. Some just haven’t caught up yet.

Putting Josh Allen at No. 5 on QB power rankings makes no sense

So because of his playoff history against the Chiefs, we’re really putting Josh Allen at No. 5? Make it make sense.

You cannot leave the reigning MVP off the top of the quarterback rankings—especially not after the season he just had. Outside of maybe Joe Burrow, no quarterback means more to his team than Josh Allen. Without him, the Bills aren’t sniffing the playoffs. They’re a five-win team, maybe.

Allen carried Buffalo to a 13–4 record with a reworked offense, set new records, and made NFL history—again. He’s consistently put the team on his back and delivered, year after year. If playoff losses to Kansas City are the only knock, then the bar is clearly skewed. Because by every other measure—production, efficiency, impact, leadership—Allen belongs at the top of the list.

Looks like 2025 will be another year of Josh Allen proving the doubters wrong. Again.

Post-draft NFL QB Power Rankings

1	Jayden Daniels Washington Commanders QB
Recency bias? Maybe. But you’d be hard-pressed to find an NFL team—contenders included—that wouldn’t jump at the chance to make him their quarterback for both now and the future. He showed remarkable poise throughout his electrifying debut season, which came just short of a Super Bowl appearance. A sophomore slump is possible, sure—but who’s to say Daniels won’t keep rising, especially with more experienced support around him in Washington?
2	Jalen Hurts Philadelphia Eagles QB
He was often—and perhaps unfairly—criticized for playing more of a supporting role during the Eagles’ Super Bowl run, but what more can you ask from him when the stakes are highest? His championship season may have confirmed he’s more effective as a selective passer than a high-volume one, but his instincts, toughness, deep-ball accuracy, and physical mobility consistently shine in critical moments.
3	Joe Burrow Cincinnati Bengals QB
The Bengals have only gone 14-13 in his starts over the past two seasons, showing that he can’t carry the team by himself. Still, when it comes to pure pocket passing, who would you choose over him? His calm under pressure and pinpoint accuracy are outstanding.
4	Lamar Jackson Baltimore Ravens QB
The playoff obstacles are still ahead, but that doesn’t take away from the fact that Jackson is an explosive force, always capable of changing the course of a game with one play thanks to his dual-threat skills.
5	Josh Allen Buffalo Bills QB
The reigning MVP is fresh off his most efficient season, working with a revamped receiving corps. But like fellow AFC star Lamar Jackson, he still hasn’t managed to step out from under the Chiefs’ shadow.
6	Patrick Mahomes Kansas City Chiefs QB
Was Mahomes’ rough Super Bowl performance just a one-off, or a sign that Kansas City can no longer rely on his late-game magic like before? A stronger group of pass-catchers could make a difference, but concerns remain with his shaky offensive line. There’s no question No. 15 remains the most dependable quarterback in the league — yet he’s now shown cracks in two major championship moments.
7	Matthew Stafford Los Angeles Rams QB
Since arriving in Los Angeles in 2021, Stafford’s career has followed two paths: he’s either been banged up and inconsistent or healthy and highly effective. At 37, it’s unclear which version will show up — but the addition of Davante Adams should provide a boost.
8	Jordan Love Green Bay Packers QB
He still shows flashes of Brett Favre, occasionally trusting his big arm a bit too much. But it’s worth noting he’s only heading into his third full season as a starter. With a healthier and upgraded group of receivers, he’s well-positioned to lead Matt LaFleur’s team back to the playoffs.
9	Jared Goff Detroit Lions QB
His usually steady and dependable presence faltered in the Lions’ surprising early playoff exit, and now he faces life without respected play-caller Ben Johnson. Even so, his classic pocket-passing style has weathered similar transitions in the past. Plus, Detroit still offers him one of the league’s top supporting casts on offense.
10	Brock Purdy San Francisco 49ers QB
Did the injury-riddled 2024 campaign pull Purdy into inconsistent territory? Absolutely. But over most of his three NFL seasons, he’s excelled as Kyle Shanahan’s field general—and he still doesn’t get enough recognition for his ability to keep plays alive.
11	Baker Mayfield Tampa Bay Buccaneers QB
It wasn’t just his 41 touchdown passes that marked him as a threat in 2024 — it was the toughness he showed leading a roster frequently hit by injuries. His gritty, never-quit attitude has become contagious in Tampa.
12	Justin Herbert Los Angeles Chargers QB
Too high? Too low? No ranking seems to fit a quarterback who tossed only three interceptions in Jim Harbaugh’s throwback offense, yet bowed out quietly once again in the playoffs. As always, the talent is undeniable.
13	C.J. Stroud Houston Texans QB
Nearly all the spark from his impressive 2023 debut was lost amid a porous offensive line and an injury-plagued unit in Year 2. Still, he never wavers as a leader. There’s reason to believe his command of the passing game will bounce back soon.
14	Dak Prescott Dallas Cowboys QB
When healthy, he can produce with the best—executing all the finer points of pocket play. But the issue, beyond lacking a signature late-season run, is his frequent unavailability; the Cowboys have had to navigate 26 games without their franchise QB since 2020.
15	Bo Nix Denver Broncos QB
Was he protected from heavy passing duties early in his career? Definitely. But by the end of his rookie season, he was delivering plenty of excitement as a playmaking leader in Sean Payton’s offense.
16	Caleb Williams Chicago Bears QB
Few young quarterbacks are better positioned for a major leap. Just as energetic and determined as he was as a rookie behind a shaky offensive line, the former No. 1 overall pick now benefits from a stronger front and a more supportive staff.
17	Geno Smith Las Vegas Raiders QB
Is he an upgrade in Las Vegas? Absolutely. At 34, Smith still has the arm strength to make deep throws. The real question is whether he can rein in his game to lead Pete Carroll’s newfound win-now team back to the playoffs.
18	Trevor LawrenceJ acksonville Jaguars QB
He may represent the biggest gap between raw talent and consistent results at the position. The physical tools are undeniable, but he’s often struggled with durability, ball control, and team support, preventing him from delivering meaningful wins. However, the addition of Travis Hunter alongside Brian Thomas Jr. could change that.
19	Drake Maye New England Patriots QB
The most impressive aspect of his rookie season was how he maintained his composure despite New England’s shaky offensive line. Now, he’s got a new coaching staff and veteran playmakers around him.
20	J.J. McCarthy Minnesota Vikings QB
A 22-year-old first-time starter with zero NFL snaps, coming off multiple knee surgeries? McCarthy’s obviously a major projection. But man is he set up to excel in Minnesota, boasting an upgraded line, elite pass targets and a beloved head coach in Kevin O’Connell. A playoff push might be the expectation.
21	Tua Tagovailoa Miami Dolphins QB
He throws a tight, accurate spiral. He’s more than capable of spreading the rock in an all-star lineup. He’s also shown repeatedly his decision-making takes a dip when he’s asked to elevate his squad on the fly. And that’s not even mentioning his concerning medical history.
22	Sam Darnold Seattle Seahawks QB
Is he the guy whose commanding arm and confidence finally showed up for much of his 2024 Vikings stint? Or the guy whose eyes got jumpy amid the heat of the moment (and extra rushers) to close his Minnesota dalliance? Probably both, which is tantalizing but unpredictable material.
23	Kyler Murray Arizona Cardinals QB
He can scurry around like few others, and he can rifle it deep fairly well. Entering Year 7 as the Cardinals’ former No. 1 pick, however, Murray’s yet to prove he can be truly steady through the air.
24	Justin Fields New York Jets QB
He registers as a solid low-risk flyer for New York, especially after a positively restrained cameo with the Steelers . The challenge has been translating his dynamic gifts into smart and splashy play.
25	Cam Ward Tennessee Titans QB
The new face of the Titans franchise, Ward may share a penchant for backyard-style ball with predecessor Will Levis. Yet his loose cannon also aided him in critical spots during his college run.
26	Bryce Young Carolina Panthers QB
Few quarterbacks enjoyed a more promising finish to 2024. Young clearly plays with a swagger bigger than his frame when he’s feeling it. The question is, what’s his ceiling even as a more confident pro? Did the Panthers really do enough out wide to give him adequate big-play support?
27	Michael Penix Jr. Atlanta Falcons QB
The man responsible for Kirk Cousins ‘ messy and prolonged attachment to the bench, Penix can sling it downfield. He also didn’t necessarily elevate Atlanta in limited action as the No. 1 in 2024.
28	Russell Wilson New York Giants QB
The favorite to headline the Giants ‘ rebooted quarterback room to start 2025, Wilson flashed his trademark play-action heaves in Pittsburgh before reverting to a more sluggish form befitting his age (36). His presence at least means New York shouldn’t have to rush Jaxson Dart into action.
29	Joe Flacco Cleveland Browns QB
Will it be Flacco leading the way to start the year, or Kenny Pickett ? Or one of their two rookies in Dillon Gabriel or Shedeur Sanders ? No matter what, Cleveland isn’t exactly built to make a run.
30	Anthony Richardson Indianapolis Colts QB
Richardson is supremely gifted with a monster arm and supersized athleticism. He’s just been entirely too erratic to keep under center with conviction. Which is why the Colts paid a not-small amount of money to Daniel Jones , another polarizing former first-rounder, as competition.
31	Mason Rudolph Pittsburgh Steelers QB
We’ll use this space to ask a simple question: How many times has Art Rooney II personally texted Aaron Rodgers , ever so gently inquiring about the 41-year-old’s plans for the 2025 season?
32	Tyler Shough New Orleans Saints QB
Technically the Saints are still Derek Carr’s team. Or are they? Carr’s status is entirely unknown as he works through a shoulder issue, but all signs indicate Shough will get a crack at QB1 duties after New Orleans spent a second-round pick on the 25-year-old Louisville product.