The St. Louis Cardinals are approaching one of the most important moments of their 2026 season as Major League Baseball’s Aug. 3 trade deadline rapidly approaches. For months, speculation has surrounded the organization regarding what direction it should take under first-year president of baseball operations Chaim Bloom. With the Cardinals sitting at 50-45 and remaining firmly in the postseason conversation, the front office faces a difficult balancing act between planning for the future and rewarding a team that has exceeded many preseason expectations.
Before Opening Day, the expectation around baseball was that St. Louis would continue its organizational reset after parting ways with several franchise cornerstones. The Cardinals had already moved on from veterans Nolan Arenado, Willson Contreras, Sonny Gray, and Brendan Donovan in an effort to replenish the farm system and reshape the roster for the future. Those trades signaled the beginning of a new era under Bloom, whose reputation was built on constructing sustainable contenders through player development and smart asset management.
However, the Cardinals’ surprising performance during the first half of the season has complicated what once appeared to be a straightforward rebuilding strategy. Instead of falling toward the bottom of the National League standings, St. Louis has remained competitive, creating legitimate debate over whether the organization should become buyers, sellers, or attempt a hybrid approach before the deadline.
Bloom’s decision over the next several weeks could shape not only the remainder of the 2026 campaign but also the franchise’s trajectory for years to come.
While several veterans have naturally emerged as potential trade candidates, there are also players whose value to the organization extends beyond what another club might offer in return. Whether because of contractual control, leadership qualities, or simply poor timing, certain Cardinals appear far more valuable staying in St. Louis than being dealt during the summer.
Here are four players the Cardinals would be wise to keep beyond the trade deadline.
Lars Nootbaar Has Become Too Important to Move Midseason
Outfielder Lars Nootbaar generated considerable trade speculation during the offseason. Given his combination of defensive versatility, offensive upside, and remaining club control, numerous contenders viewed him as an attractive trade target.
That speculation cooled considerably after Nootbaar underwent offseason heel surgery, temporarily creating uncertainty regarding his availability entering the season. Since returning to full health, however, he has reminded everyone why he remains one of the organization’s most valuable position players.
More importantly, Nootbaar has evolved into one of the team’s emotional leaders.
His energy, consistency, and clubhouse presence have become increasingly valuable during a season in which many veteran leaders departed. On a relatively young roster, his influence extends well beyond his statistical production.
Had the Cardinals fallen completely out of playoff contention, moving Nootbaar might have been a logical step to maximize his trade value. Multiple clubs likely would have offered significant prospect packages for a controllable outfielder capable of contributing immediately to a postseason contender.
But circumstances have changed.
St. Louis remains in the race, and removing one of its most dependable everyday players could negatively impact both the clubhouse and the team’s chances of remaining competitive through September.
Additionally, Nootbaar still has another full season of team control remaining after 2026. That means Bloom isn’t facing pressure to make a decision immediately.
If the organization ultimately concludes that Nootbaar isn’t part of its long-term plans, there will still be opportunities to revisit trade discussions during the offseason when more teams are willing to negotiate and player movement generally becomes less disruptive.
Waiting several months could also produce stronger offers while allowing the Cardinals to finish evaluating the current roster.
Riley O’Brien Has Emerged as the Bullpen’s Cornerstone
Every successful team needs a reliable closer, and Riley O’Brien has firmly established himself in that role.
After earning the first All-Star selection of his major league career, O’Brien has become one of the National League’s more dependable late-inning relievers. Through 39 appearances, he owns a 3.43 ERA while converting 24 save opportunities, consistently protecting leads for a Cardinals club that has relied heavily on its bullpen throughout the season.
Elite relievers routinely become some of the hottest commodities at the trade deadline. Contending teams often overpay for bullpen help, especially closers capable of pitching in high-pressure postseason situations.
That reality naturally places O’Brien among players other organizations would love to acquire.
Yet the Cardinals have little reason to rush into such a move.
Unlike veteran relievers approaching free agency, O’Brien remains under team control for four additional seasons. That lengthy window dramatically increases his value to St. Louis.
Rather than viewing him solely as a trade asset, Bloom can realistically envision O’Brien anchoring the bullpen throughout the club’s next competitive cycle.
Even if the Cardinals eventually decide to move him, there is no urgency.
A reliever with four years of control should retain substantial trade value during the offseason, next year’s deadline, or even later if necessary.
Keeping O’Brien also sends an important message to the clubhouse that productive young contributors won’t automatically be traded simply because rebuilding organizations traditionally sell at the deadline.
His presence stabilizes the bullpen while preserving flexibility for future roster decisions.
Nolan Gorman’s Trade Value Simply Isn’t There Right Now
Few players have experienced a more frustrating 2026 season than infielder Nolan Gorman.
Once viewed as one of the Cardinals’ cornerstone young power hitters, Gorman has struggled to establish consistency offensively, leading the organization to demote him to Triple-A earlier this year.
Those struggles have naturally fueled speculation that a change of scenery might ultimately benefit both player and organization.
In many ways, that possibility remains realistic.
Sometimes talented players simply need a fresh environment, and Gorman may eventually thrive elsewhere if given that opportunity.
However, timing matters.
Trading Gorman while his value sits near its lowest point would likely produce disappointing returns.
Opposing front offices understand his recent struggles just as well as the Cardinals do. Rather than paying for his previous prospect pedigree, interested clubs would almost certainly attempt to acquire him at a significant discount.
That would represent poor asset management.
Instead, St. Louis should allow Gorman to finish the season in Triple-A, giving him time to regain confidence, refine his swing, and demonstrate that his offensive potential still exists.
If he finishes the year strongly, his trade value could rebound considerably.
Conversely, if he returns to the major leagues and begins producing again, the Cardinals might even reconsider whether moving him remains the best course of action.
Either outcome provides more information than an immediate deadline trade would.
The offseason will offer Bloom additional time to evaluate Gorman’s development while exploring a broader trade market that often produces more creative deals than those completed during the pressure-filled days leading up to the deadline.
There simply appears to be far more upside in waiting than selling low today.
Pedro Pagés Still Fills an Important Role
The Cardinals arguably possess one of baseball’s deepest collections of catching talent.
Pedro Pagés, Iván Herrera, and top prospect Jimmy Crooks have all factored into discussions regarding the future behind the plate.
Depth at catcher often creates trade opportunities, particularly when contenders seek experienced defensive options before the postseason.
On paper, Pagés could appear expendable.
In reality, the situation isn’t nearly that simple.
Although Herrera continues developing offensively and Crooks remains one of the organization’s more intriguing young prospects, neither player has completely seized control of the starting catching job.
Questions remain regarding consistency, durability, and long-term roles.
That uncertainty makes Pagés considerably more valuable than some might assume.
Reliable catching depth is one of baseball’s most difficult resources to replace, especially during the second half of the season when injuries become increasingly common.
Moving Pagés now would leave the Cardinals with significantly less flexibility should either Herrera or Crooks encounter setbacks.
Additionally, Pagés has demonstrated the ability to work effectively with the pitching staff while providing dependable defense behind the plate.
Those qualities often become even more valuable during meaningful games late in the season.
Unless another organization overwhelms St. Louis with an exceptional offer, retaining Pagés appears to be the smarter baseball decision.
Bloom Must Balance Today With Tomorrow
The Cardinals’ situation entering the trade deadline differs dramatically from what many analysts predicted several months ago.
Rather than conducting another large-scale sell-off, Bloom now faces a far more nuanced challenge.
The organization certainly should continue listening to offers involving veterans whose contracts are nearing expiration or players unlikely to fit long-term plans.
At the same time, not every productive player should automatically become available simply because the Cardinals entered the season expecting to reshape the roster.
Organizations build sustained winners by recognizing which players possess greater value on the field than they would generate in trade packages.
Nootbaar, O’Brien, Gorman, and Pagés each represent different examples of that philosophy.
Nootbaar provides leadership and everyday production.
O’Brien anchors the bullpen with multiple years of affordable team control.
Gorman deserves an opportunity to rebuild his value rather than being traded at his lowest point.
Pagés offers stability at one of baseball’s most demanding positions while the organization continues evaluating its long-term catching picture.
Whether the Cardinals ultimately buy, sell, or pursue a balanced strategy before Aug. 3, holding onto these four players could prove to be one of the organization’s smartest decisions.
The trade deadline always creates pressure to make headlines, but successful front offices understand that sometimes the best move is resisting the temptation to make one. For a Cardinals club still chasing postseason baseball while simultaneously building for the future, patience may ultimately become one of Chaim Bloom’s most valuable assets.
READ MORE
